Top-rated Tire Shops in Jacksonville
Need tires in Jacksonville? The shops below have all earned 4.0 stars or higher from real customers — new tires, rotations, balancing, alignments, and flat repairs — these are the tire pros locals trust for fair prices and straight answers.
19 top-rated pros · Updated from Google this week
TopRatedJacksonville is an independent directory. We are not affiliated with Google, and not affiliated with or endorsed by any business listed here. Business details, ratings, review counts and photos are sourced from Google. Claiming a listing affects only this directory — it has no connection to a business's Google Business Profile.
By the numbers · Jacksonville, FL
Across the 19 businesses we track, the median rating is 4.7★ across 16,355 combined customer reviews.
8 of the 19 have cleared the toughest bar — 4.8★ with at least 50 reviews.
Review depth varies widely — the most-reviewed business carries 3,971 reviews against a 861 average — so weigh each rating against how many customers stand behind it.
19 businesses
Adam Automotive & Tire Shop LLC
Plus Tires Brakes Oil change
Sam’s Tire Outlet
Big Discount Tire Alignment Brakes Oil Change Auto Care
Bargain Tires
Tire City Outlet
Bargain Tires
Amigos tire shop
Jax tire shop service
QUALITY USED TIRES LLC
Tire Man beaver st
Los Brothers Tires
Tire Depot
Robert's Tire & Wheel
Ameer Used Tires
Sunny Tires
Kings Rd. Tire Shop
L&H Tires LLC
Steve's Tire Empire
How to choose a tire shop
A good tire shop helps you choose the right tire for your vehicle, driving, and budget rather than steering you to the most expensive option — and it is upfront that the “out-the-door” price includes mounting, balancing, valve stems, and disposal, which is where quotes quietly differ. Ask whether they offer a road-hazard warranty and free rotations, which add real value over the life of the tires.
For service beyond tires — alignments, flat repairs, TPMS sensors — look for clear pricing and honest advice about what you actually need. Reviews mentioning fair quotes, quick turnaround, and no-pressure recommendations are the signal to trust. Comparing the full installed price across a couple of shops is worth the few minutes.
Frequently asked questions
How much do new tires cost in Jacksonville?
It depends on tire size and quality, and the total should include mounting, balancing, new valve stems, and old-tire disposal. Ask for the “out-the-door” price so you can compare shops on equal footing.
How often should I rotate my tires?
Most manufacturers recommend every 5,000 to 8,000 miles to even out wear and extend tire life. Many shops include free rotations when you buy tires from them — worth asking about.
Do I need an alignment with new tires?
It is often recommended, since poor alignment wears new tires quickly and unevenly. A shop should check and tell you if it is needed rather than automatically adding it — ask to see the alignment readings.
How do I know when I need new tires?
Check tread depth (the penny test), and watch for uneven wear, cracking, vibration, or frequent flats. A reputable shop will show you the wear rather than just telling you to replace them.
Why you can trust this list
Every business featured on TopRatedJacksonville has earned at least a 4.0-star rating from 15 or more real customer reviews — if a company has not cleared that bar, you will not find it here. Those scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us, and a business cannot pay to raise its rating.
We update our data periodically so the tire shops you see reflect how they are serving Jacksonville today. Listings marked as verified have confirmed their business details directly.